Bake Me A Wish Reviews

Total rating 2.43

Poor

TrustScore calculated from 7 reviews

Bad
42%
Poor
28%
Average
0%
Great
0%
Excellent
28%

Description Bake Me A Wish

Bake Me A Wish! began in 2005 as the premiere nationwide service for gourmet birthday cake delivery. Our cakes are made with only the finest, freshest ingredients by our award-winning New York bakeries. Over the past decade, we've grown to offer more and more of the finest bakery gifts available including gourmet cookies, brownies, cupcakes, pies and quiches. There is no better way to celebrate a special occasion than to send a little indulgence from someone who cares. Our Guarantee: On-Time Delivery and a Quality Gift.

We set up a hassle-free process with customizable options at every turn and soon enough, customers fell in love with our sumptuous recipes, personalized greeting cards and elegant packaging. 15 years later, we’ve come to offer a magnificent lineup of other mouthwatering bakery treats including cookies, brownies, cupcakes, pies and quiches. We’re expanding our offering even further with gorgeous snack and fruit baskets. We’ve become the go-to source for people in need of high-quality baked goods, and we’re excited to help make your gifting dreams come true.


- bad
Jassie, 2021-06-02

I sent an email multiple time requesting assistance and received no reply prior to posting this comment. I wouldn't recommend this company to anyone even if they were giving away their product - TERRIBLE CUSTOMER SERVICE. All they had to do was to no respond!!! Extremely disappointed.

Do you find this review useful?

  0   1
- Excellent
Yissette, 2021-05-16

The cakes were amazing in taste ans since there was 3 small separate cakes they were individually packaged which was fantastic for storing them for later to eat. Great over all company. Glad we chose them.

Do you find this review useful?

  0   1
- Poor
Emiing, 2021-03-23

I bought a carrot cake for my mother’s birthday. It was delivered on time and looked very nice. Mom was excited to receive it. However when she had a slice she bit down into something hard. She thinks it is a piece of bone. She threw out the cake. I contacted the company via their “contact us” form, described the situation and noted that I have a picture of the hard object. I have heard nothing from them. No response at all.

Do you find this review useful?

  0   1
- Poor
Emiing, 2021-02-13

I bought a carrot cake for my mother’s birthday. It was delivered on time and looked very nice. Mom was excited to receive it. However when she had a slice she bit down into something hard. She thinks it is a piece of bone. She threw out the cake. I contacted the company via their “contact us” form, described the situation and noted that I have a picture of the hard object. I have heard nothing from them. No response at all.

Do you find this review useful?

  0   1
- Excellent
Yissette, 2021-01-31

The cakes were amazing in taste ans since there was 3 small separate cakes they were individually packaged which was fantastic for storing them for later to eat. Great over all company. Glad we chose them.

Do you find this review useful?

  0   1
- bad
Janeese, 2020-09-30

having it as my Wedding Cake I was SO disappointed. It was so sweet NO one would eat it! It was not edible. Traditionally a yummy cream cheese topping and layering was nothing like that. All you could taste was SUGAR. The cake was thin and no one even wanted to scrape the icing off and give it a go. I have never met a cake I didn’t like until now.

Do you find this review useful?

  0   1
- bad
Jassie, 2020-06-15

I sent an email multiple time requesting assistance and received no reply prior to posting this comment. I wouldn't recommend this company to anyone even if they were giving away their product - TERRIBLE CUSTOMER SERVICE. All they had to do was to no respond!!! Extremely disappointed.

Do you find this review useful?

  0   1

Terms and Conditions

Log in

Or

If there is an account with this email address you will receive instructions for resetting the password on it!